RailOP

RailOP Problem/Feature Request Tracker

(Signup or Login to report a problem or request a feature.)

  

Viewing Issue Simple Details Jump to Notes ] << ][ >> ] View Advanced ] Issue History ] #Print ]
ID Category Severity Reproducibility Date Submitted Last Update
0000044 [RailOP] Bug major always 03-25-08 18:00 08-07-08 22:55
Reporter inspectordave View Status public  
Assigned To ericd
Priority normal Resolution fixed  
Status resolved   Product Version 8.1
Summary 0000044: Trains that orginate from a major yard do not autobuild correctly
Description In version 8.0, trains that originated in a main yard, autobuilt correctly. Trains leaving, from the yard, would have the proper cars. CNW cars were assigned to a CNW train. In versions 8.1 and beyond, trains that originate from the main yard were assigned cars from any railroad in that yard. For instance, in version 8.0 a BNSF train would receive cars that had a BNSF designation sitting in the yard. Autobuild assigned BNSF cars to this train. A CNW would receive cars that were waitng for a CNW train. In versions 8.1 and beyond, autobuild just grabs any car and places it on a train regardless of what railroad the car was supposed to go to. However autobuild works just fine for trains that are passing through the yard, grabbing the proper cars and placing them in the proper train. Just trains that originate from the yard is where autobuild has this bug. 8.0 autobuild is fine, 8.1 it is not.
Additional Information
Additional Notes
- Notes
(0000021)
ericd
07-25-08 02:42

Dave, I ran a test in the latest test version. I created three towns, one set up with its yard for all roads, the other two yards for a specific road. (This was set at the siding level - not the train). All of the cars were routed correctly. However, was your yards set up as yard tracks or interchange tracks? That could make a difference and I would like to try and duplicate your settings to make sure this is really not happening on the test version.

Thanks, Eric
 
(0000024)
inspectordave
07-25-08 07:54

Eric

Create tracks 1 and 2 and 3 as interchanges with the BNSF. Place cars on these tracks so they are set for one railroad. Example, track 0000001 have all cars placed there set to go to the CNW, track 0000002 all go to the UP, track 0000003 all go to the CP. Tracks 4,5 and 6 have just BNSF for the railroad assigned to them. Now build a local that leaves the yard and it is a BNSF train. Autobuild "should" grab cars from 4,5 and 6. However, RailOp will grab cars from track 0000001, which is the interchange with the CNW and all cars on that track are set to go to a CNW train.
 
(0000028)
ericd
07-26-08 22:43

Thanks for the additional info. I have been able to get it to happen consistently using your setup.
 
(0000032)
ericd
08-03-08 19:19

Dave:

I have uploaded a file to the support site. If you can download it and test, it should resolve this issue. If it continues to not pick the cars up properly, not the ticket on the support site and I'll dig deeper.

This test version is 8.2.9.85.
 
(0000033)
inspectordave
08-03-08 23:15

Eric

It seems to be working correctly now. I have a copy of my friend's RailOp here and that is where we had to use some creative thinking so trains built from his main yard built correctly. I checked this fix here as well as there and yes, you fixed it!! Thank you.

later

Dave
Trempealeau WI
 
(0000034)
inspectordave
08-03-08 23:17

Eric

It seems to be working correctly now. I have a copy of my friend's RailOp here and that is where we had to use some creative thinking so trains built from his main yard built correctly. I checked this fix here as well as there and yes, you fixed it!! Thank you.

later

Dave
Trempealeau WI
 
Attached Files


- Relationships

- Issue History
Date Modified Username Field Change
03-25-08 18:00 inspectordave New Issue
07-25-08 02:42 ericd Note Added: 0000021
07-25-08 02:44 ericd Status new => assigned
07-25-08 02:44 ericd Assigned To  => ericd
07-25-08 07:54 inspectordave Note Added: 0000024
07-25-08 07:56 inspectordave Note Added: 0000025
07-25-08 08:12 inspectordave Note Deleted: 0000025
07-26-08 22:43 ericd Note Added: 0000028
07-26-08 22:43 ericd Status assigned => confirmed
08-03-08 19:18 ericd File Added: RailOp.exe
08-03-08 19:19 ericd Note Added: 0000032
08-03-08 23:15 inspectordave Note Added: 0000033
08-03-08 23:17 inspectordave Note Added: 0000034
08-07-08 22:53 ericd File Deleted: RailOp.exe
08-07-08 22:54 ericd Status confirmed => resolved
08-07-08 22:54 ericd Fixed in Version  => 8.3.0
08-07-08 22:54 ericd Resolution open => fixed


Copyright © 2000 - 2007 Mantis Group
71 total queries executed.
45 unique queries executed.
Powered by Mantis Bugtracker